Remy, just out of a relationship gone wrong, meets handsome Jeremy, the boy next door. Jeremy exudes an air of mystery, and he seems to be everything she's looking for. While Remy allows herself to indulge in the idea of love at first site, she realizes she's the girl next door according to her boss, Dr. Samuel Kendrick. For the first time in her life, Remy has the luxury of choosing between the handsome young neighbor and her upstanding-and-sometimes-uptight boss. The situation intensifies when Barbara arrives, claiming to be an ex-beau of Jeremy and pregnant with his child. Is Jeremy who he claims to be? Is Sam on the level? What does Remy do? Does she pick the right man?