Englischer Paige Cross is excited about her upcoming marriage to her Amish beau Jacob Brenneman, but she is haunted by the memory of her twin brother Ben who still belongs to a religious cult. After realizing that she could never marry Jacob, knowing she harbored such a deep secret, she finally opens up to him. Caleb doesn't think twice when he enlists the help of Darla Grover, the woman who originally saved Paige. He couldn't bear the thought of seeing Paige suffer like this. And he's willing to put his own life on the line to ensure that his future wife is reunited with her twin brother.