Eight years ago, Tony bailed on Olivia at the altar. In the days leading up to the wedding, Olivia wasn't the bubbly girl Tony fell in love with. She'd turned into more of a "I'm fine, nothing's wrong" kind of girl that he didn't recognize. He concluded she didn't want to marry him and was too shy to admit it. So, he gave her a get-out-of-jail-free card by taking all the blame for the wedding that never was.

Fast forward to today. Tony's back in town and now they're forced to work together. Sparks fly, and Olivia's heart does the cha-cha every time Tony gets close. But can she trust him? Besides, she's engaged to someone else, and even if her heart only flutters for Tony, not her nice, "safe" fiancé, she's not about to humiliate him like she was humiliated. Though she never understood why Tony left her at the altar, she was secretly relieved she didn't have to get married that day.

Can Tony and Olivia work through the past, or will she walk down the aisle with her safe bet? This time, will Tony end up alone at the altar?